Sample reports
Each card opens a long-form illustrative sample showing how reviewer-style feedback could look for a fictional manuscript in that specialty. The featured neurosurgery example uses the full on-site report layout — the same components a real review renders.
Report bodies are shown in English.
Fictional cohort manuscript rendered with the same ReviewDisplay components used for live reviews. Explore scoring, axis breakdown, references and action plan.
Open interactive sampleNine illustrative scenarios. Each opens a dedicated page with reviewer-style commentary and a checklist.
Phase II single-arm trial with biomarker-selected cohort — endpoint hierarchy, multiplicity, and overclaim review.
View sampleRetrospective surgical series — complication definitions, follow-up gaps, and comparative-language audit.
View sampleRegistry analysis with device exposure — time-zero alignment, immortal time, and risk-model calibration.
View sampleOutbreak investigation — case definitions, sampling frame, and uncertainty in public-health claims.
View sampleCohort with patient-reported outcomes — scale handling, blinding, and reporting completeness.
View sampleDiagnostic accuracy study — spectrum bias, reader variability, and reference-standard transparency.
View samplePediatric trial — age-stratified outcomes, ethics framing, and generalisability discussion.
View sampleImplant cohort — surgeon volume effects, patient-reported outcomes, and follow-up adequacy.
View sampleObservational cohort across comorbidities — confounder handling, missingness, and scope alignment.
View sampleLooking for editorial guidance?
Ten editorial patterns that drive triage rejections, organised by specialty. Each guide is a separate page so you can deep-link from a manuscript review.
Browse desk-reject guides